In Chinese history, the Three Kingdoms period was an era filled with heroes and outstanding figures. Among them, Guan Yu, as one of the Five Tiger Generals of Shu Han, has been renowned for his martial prowess and loyalty by later generations. However, there are different accounts regarding the cause of his death in history. One widely circulated story is that Guan Yu's family was killed by the son of Pang De. Is this story a true historical event or a legend fabricated by later generations? This article will unravel this mystery for you.

First, we need to understand the background of this story. In the 24th year of Jian'an (219 AD), Guan Yu, a general of Shu Han, defeated the famous Wei general Pang De in the battle of Fancheng. Pang De was captured alive, but he resolutely refused to surrender and was ultimately beheaded. It is said that before Pang De's death, he shouted, "My son will surely take revenge!" This foreshadowed the later story.

However, there is no conclusive historical evidence for the claim that Pang De's son killed Guan Yu's family. In the official historical records such as the "Records of the Three Kingdoms," this event is not mentioned. Instead, Guan Yu's death was primarily due to his defeat by the Eastern Wu general Lu Meng in the battle of Maicheng, followed by his capture and execution.

Why did such a story arise? This may be related to the shaping of heroic images in later generations. In ancient Chinese culture, concepts such as loyalty, righteousness, and revenge were deeply ingrained. Pang De, as a loyal and valiant general, having his son avenge his death aligns perfectly with people's expectations of heroic figures. Therefore, although this story lacks historical basis, it has gained widespread dissemination and recognition.

Additionally, this story may also be a misunderstanding of historical events. In the wars of that era, the enmity and grudges between soldiers and generals were extremely complex. If Pang De's son truly existed, he may have joined the Eastern Wu in order to avenge his father. However, this does not necessarily mean that he was the culprit who killed Guan Yu's family. In fact, Guan Yu's death was more attributed to his defeat in the war and strategic errors.

In conclusion, the claim that Pang De's son killed Guan Yu's family is actually a historical misunderstanding. Although this story is widely circulated, it does not conform to historical facts. Through exploring this period of history, we can gain a better understanding of the complexity of ancient Chinese wars and the differences between historical legends and real events. At the same time, we should also cherish the heroes who have made great contributions to our country and nation, inheriting their loyalty and bravery.

　　Disclaimer: The above content is sourced from the internet and the copyright belongs to the original author. If there is any infringement of your original copyright, please inform us and we will delete the relevant content as soon as possible.